Killer Who Buried Lake County Teen Softball Star in Strawberry Patch to Walk Free After Serving 40 Years In Prison

Michelle Hayes’ family urges the community to stay vigilant after Scott Grant’s release.

August 21, 2026

This article was last updated by Alisha Shrestha on August 21, 2026

The community of Lake County is on high alert as convicted killer and registered sex offender Scott Grant walks free after serving four decades in prison.

Grant, now 58, was originally for the brutal death of 17-year-old Michelle Hayes in 1985.

His release has reignited pain for the victim’s family and raised concerns about public safety.

Michelle Hayes, a student at Mentor High School, was attacked after rejecting Grant’s sexual advances.

Grant, along with a 16-year-old accomplice, beat and dismembered her before burying her body in a neighbor’s strawberry patch.

While the accomplice has since passed away, Grant served a 40-year sentence at the Lake Erie Correctional Institution in Conneaut.

Community members fear the danger of having the Lake County killer free once again (Source: Facebook)

Dawn Hayes, Michelle’s sister, expressed deep anguish over Grant’s release.

“It’s a nightmare that you never wake up from, ever. She is terribly missed, even to this day,” Dawn .

She criticized the justice system for a mistrial that prevented a life sentence, arguing that Grant’s crimes demanded far harsher punishment.

The victim’s niece, Lauren Godec, also shared her frustration.

“We’ll keep fighting every chance we get. You want to be at peace, and you’re not because you’re constantly fighting to keep someone behind bars who deserves to be there for life,” Godec explained.

Online court records confirm that Grant must register as a sex offender, but the family warns the public that he is now a free man.

Dawn Hayes advised community members to stay vigilant and use available resources, such as free apps, to monitor nearby sex offenders.

John Whited, a former classmate of Michelle, emphasized her good character.

“I don’t think anybody could say anything bad about her,” he said.

He added that the thought of Grant living freely in the community is deeply unsettling.

As the Lake County community processes the reality of the Lake County killer’s freedom, Hayes’ family hopes sharing Michelle’s story will protect others and prevent future tragedies.

• Check other Articles on

Related articles

May 13, 2026

May 12, 2026

May 12, 2026

May 8, 2026

Comments

LEAVE A REPLY

Comment: Please enter your comment! Name:* Please enter your name here Email:* You have entered an incorrect email address! Please enter your email address here

Δ

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam.

Share article

- May 13, 2026 Residents of Biggleswade, Bedfordshire, are raising serious concerns after a series of violent incidents involving a group of young boys who have been targeting...

- May 13, 2026 Andrew O' Donnell of Fairfield, Connecticut, passed away at the age of 39. He was born in Fairfield, Connecticut, and later moved to Ancramdale, New...

- May 12, 2026 Judy (Evans) Milby of Rockwall, Texas, passed away on Saturday at the age of 80. Milby was born on July 25, 1945, to her father,...

- May 12, 2026 Residents of Dromore, Co. Down, are calling for action after a deeply concerning incident at the local play park, where older children were reported...

- May 11, 2026 A video circulating on Facebook has sparked a heated debate among Bell Gardens residents after police were called on a group of kids riding...